GTM for Marketplace Businesses

The chicken-and-egg problem defines marketplace GTM. You need supply to attract demand and demand to attract supply. Most marketplace launches fail because they solve this problem incorrectly. The winners understand when to prioritize supply, when to prioritize demand, and how to engineer liquidity into the system from day one.

Understanding the marketplace GTM challenge

A marketplace is a platform that connects two distinct user groups. Suppliers offer goods or services. Demanders want to consume those goods or services. Your success depends on how well you balance supply and demand. Too much supply with no demand creates an empty marketplace. Too much demand with no supply leaves users frustrated.

This two-sided nature makes GTM fundamentally different from single-sided products. You cannot simply acquire one side first and expect the other to follow. You must engineer liquidity and build both sides in parallel, with deliberate prioritization.

The chicken-and-egg problem: Supply-first vs demand-first

Supply-first strategy

Supply-first means recruiting suppliers before recruiting demand. You spend time and effort getting providers like restaurants, drivers, or freelancers to join your platform first, then recruit consumers to use them.

When to use supply-first is when supply is expensive to recruit but willing to join because restaurants need customers, so offering them a customer acquisition channel is attractive. Demand is cheap to recruit but difficult to satisfy without supply where consumers will try a marketplace if enough supply exists.

Example is Uber started in San Francisco by recruiting drivers first, then consumers followed because the supply was visible. DoorDash did the same by recruiting restaurants, then acquiring diners.

Demand-first strategy

Demand-first means recruiting consumers before recruiting suppliers. You build a large consumer base first, then suppliers join because they see the potential customer base.

When to use demand-first is when supply is easy to recruit but not yet motivated to join where suppliers will join if they see demand. Demand is expensive to recruit but willing to try new marketplaces.

Example is Airbnb started by recruiting hosts as supply in Brooklyn and NYC through direct outreach, but then used demand growth to recruit more hosts. They did hybrid, but demand growth was a key lever for host acquisition.

Hybrid (balanced) strategy

Recruit both sides in parallel, managing ratio carefully. For every one supplier, recruit 2-3 demanders. This creates a perception of abundant choice without oversupply.

Seeding strategies for marketplaces

Founder-driven seeding

Founders or early team members manually recruit the first suppliers and demanders. Spend 50% of time on supply recruitment through cold outreach, direct relationships, and incentives and 50% on demand recruitment through paid ads, SEO, and referrals. This is expensive but builds product-supplier-demand fit.

Incentive-driven seeding

Subsidize supply or demand to create liquidity. Uber subsidized both drivers through sign-up bonuses and guaranteed minimums and riders through free credits to create a virtuous cycle. This accelerates seeding but requires capital.

Exclusive seeding

Launch in a small geographic area or vertical where supply and demand are concentrated and easy to reach. Establish strong liquidity in that micromarket first, then expand. This is how Uber, Airbnb, and Meesho grew by dominating one market, then expanding.

Operator-sourced seeding

Use your existing network or partnerships to seed supply. If you have relationships with restaurants, recruit them first. If you have users from a previous product, recruit them as demanders. This reduces cold acquisition cost.

Liquidity metrics for marketplaces

Gross merchandise value (GMV)

GMV is the total value of transactions on your marketplace. It is the headline metric for marketplace success. GMV growth correlates with supply and demand health. GMV target is 50-100% YoY growth for healthy marketplaces.

Take rate

Take rate is the percentage of each transaction you keep with the rest going to suppliers. Healthy take rates range from 10-30% depending on your category. Too low and you do not have a viable business. Too high and suppliers feel squeezed and leave for competitors.

Liquidity score

Liquidity is the availability of supply and demand at the same time and place. A marketplace with high supply but low demand, or vice versa, has low liquidity. Measure liquidity through active supply as percentage of suppliers listing in last 30 days, active demand as percentage of demanders making purchase in last 30 days, supply-to-demand ratio showing how many suppliers per demander, and repeat rate as percentage of demanders making multiple purchases.

Net revenue retention (supply-side)

How much revenue retained from existing suppliers versus lost to churn or competition. High NRR means suppliers are sticking around and deepening usage. Low NRR signals dissatisfaction with take rate, lack of demand, or switching to competitors.

The marketplace flywheel

A healthy marketplace flywheel works as follows. More supply attracts more demand. More demand attracts more supply. Both grow together in a reinforcing loop. The trick is seeding this loop. Once it starts spinning, it compounds exponentially.

Example is Uber’s flywheel where more drivers appear instantly on the map, decreasing wait times for riders. Shorter wait times make riders use Uber more frequently. Increased rider volume attracts more drivers who want steady demand. The flywheel spins.

Pricing and take rate strategy

Your take rate is your business model. Too low and you cannot afford operations and growth. Too high and suppliers leave you for competitors. Start conservative at 10-15% to attract suppliers and build network effects. Increase take rate gradually at 1-2% annually as supply becomes scarce and demanders become sticky.

Segment pricing charges different take rates for different supplier segments. Premium suppliers with high ratings and high volume get better rates to keep them. Weak suppliers pay higher rates. This incentivizes quality and keeps top performers.

Vertical vs horizontal marketplaces

Vertical marketplaces

Vertical marketplaces focus on one category or service like food delivery, rides, or home cleaning. Easier to launch because supply and demand are concentrated. Easier to dominate a vertical. Examples include DoorDash for food and Uber for rides.

Horizontal marketplaces

Horizontal marketplaces span multiple categories like services marketplace offering cleaning, handyman, and pet care. Harder to launch because supply and demand are diffuse. But once established, easier to expand to new categories. Example is TaskRabbit.

Geographic expansion strategy

Expand geographically in concentric circles. Dominate your home city first, then expand to adjacent cities, then region, then nationally. Do not try to expand to 50 cities with weak supply and demand in each. Dominate the top 3 markets first, then expand.

Marketplace examples

Uber

Supply-first strategy in concentrated geographies like SF and NYC. Massive driver incentives with $1,000 plus sign-up bonuses and rider subsidies with $20 credits created initial liquidity. Dominated each city before expanding. Vertical focus on rides, then expanded to Eats. Currently operates in 70 plus countries.

Airbnb

Hybrid strategy with early operator seeding. Founders did door-to-door recruiting in Brooklyn. Then pivoted to demand recruitment to drive host growth. Strong community building through Instagram and events created brand love that attracted hosts. Now 7M plus listings.

Meesho

India-focused supply-first marketplace. Meesho recruits small entrepreneurs, mostly women, as sellers and connects them to consumers. Focuses on low-cost social commerce through WhatsApp and Facebook. Currently $5B plus valuation, defying marketplace economics by focusing on underserved sellers and buyers.

Common marketplace GTM mistakes

Building without seeding. Launching a marketplace with zero supply and expecting demand to appear through marketing is futile. Seed manually first, optimize later.

Not managing supply-demand ratio. Running out of supply while you have demand kills marketplaces. Actively manage the ratio and recruit supply proportionally to demand growth.

Too-high take rate early. Suppliers will not join if your take rate is 30% when competitors charge 15%. Start low, build network effects, then increase gradually.

Expanding geographically too early. Do not expand to 20 cities with weak liquidity in each. Dominate 3 cities first, then expand. Quality beats quantity.

Not building trust mechanisms. Without review systems, payment protection, and dispute resolution, marketplaces fail. Build trust infrastructure early.

About upGrowth

upGrowth is a growth marketing agency specializing in SEO, GEO (Generative Engine Optimization), and AI-first digital strategies. With 40+ documented growth case studies and proprietary frameworks, upGrowth helps brands build visibility across both traditional search engines and AI-powered discovery platforms. These entity pages are part of the upGrowth Entity Hub, a definitive reference library for modern search and AI optimization concepts.