Contributors:
Amol Ghemud Published: August 14, 2018
In This Article
Share On:
Companies, today, are focusing on doing what they do best, developing their core strengths. Marketing program is one such important step in the business cycle of a company, and for a great marketing strategy, you need professionalism in your approach. While it is great for establishing clarity and channeling the energy of the organization, there are certain things that just cannot be avoided such as website design, content creation, or marketing campaigns. Companies, often look to hire marketing professionals, but the dilemma they have to face is whether to go for an agency vs. freelancer.
Freelancers and Agencies
They are independent workers, that are not affiliated with any organization and work on a project to project basis. Freelancers are usually experts in a particular field, Eg. Writing, Social media, Graphic design, etc. They charge by the hour or day or per project depending on the kind and amount of work to be done. On the other hand, agencies provide services as an organization to other companies, organizations or other corporate entities. Agencies, usually comprise of a number of freelancers who are experts in different fields. They can provide more holistic or complete solutions given that they have more people on board, and thus have a broader range of skills.
Freelancer or Agency: Who is Better for Marketing Campaigns
Here are a few factors that might help you evaluate and decide what works for your marketing strategy
Cost
If you are thinking why hire a freelancer, cost can be a factor as freelancers price themselves for their services and are in most cases relatively cost-effective. They don’t have any significant overheads to factor in. But for more complicated projects you might have to hire multiple freelancers for different aspects of the job, which can be costlier in the long run. Agencies, on the other hand, can be costly, as they have overheads such as office space, project coordinators, etc. But when you hire an agency you state your requirements and the onus falls on them to find people with the required skill set for the project, that leaves you with much less to worry about.
Expertise
Freelancers are usually very good at what they do. Most of them specialize in one or two fields, e.g., Writing, and Social media marketing. So, they might suit your requirements in specific smaller projects, but the lack of skills in other critical aspects of your marketing strategy can sometimes be a big limitation.
The companies hiring freelancers would be really lucky to find a superhuman freelancer with multiple abilities in the real world. Agencies meanwhile put together the team according to the project’s requirements. Individuals with expertise in various fields work together under the supervision of a project manager, to make sure that all aspects are coming along in sync. For eg:- If you hire an agency to get a website up , they would have designers, developers and content writers in a team to provide a complete solution. Whereas if you are going for the freelance professional services, you would have to look for each of them separately.
Availability and Support
While most freelancers are dependent on work from multiple sources, it is possible that the one you want might be unavailable when you need them. Also, most freelancers have tight schedules or even have different full-time jobs. That’s why getting in touch can be difficult sometimes. Since they keep moving on to other projects, support after completion is also limited. The difference with agencies is that you don’t have to ask them for availability. Most agencies will provide you with a project coordinator or manager to be your POC and help you track progress. Regular updates are provided, and suggestions/feedbacks are sought and then implemented.
Reliability and Professionalism
Most freelancers are passionate about what they do and take it seriously. They will push themselves to make sure they deliver the best they can, even working late nights or on weekends to accommodate your requirements. But sometimes due to certain circumstances, they might have to abandon a project , or they might be unresponsive to emails, procrastinate and miss deadlines. It can, in turn, affect your marketing campaign adversely. Agencies have teams in place, that can continue to work on the project even in the event of minor hiccups such as a member lagging behind with their deliverables or falling sick. They can work together to stay on track, and the agency might also allocate additional resources too if it is required to meet the deadlines and are generally more reliable.
Want to use growth hacks to boost your startup or business?
When your marketing and the quality of the product starts paying off, and you start growing, your requirements can change. You target new demographics or markets, and your outreach increases significantly. While freelancers can provide great ideas, it is very difficult for them to scale. But with an agency, they can keep pace with your growth, by allocating more resources accordingly. They can adapt to your requirements, and make strategies as per the type and scale of audience.
2. Hiring an Agency is The Long-Term Solution
As mentioned earlier working with agencies makes it easier to establish a long-term relationship, and the dynamics improve as they keep working with you and understand your requirements better. Unlike with freelancers, where you would have to start everything from scratch with everyone you bring on board. With agencies, you just have to give a brief to the manager, and they communicate it to their team. Work goes along in a more structured way.
Agencies can also be held more accountable since there is a manager or coordinator, you don’t have to manage each freelancer and also not have to worry about anyone dropping your project since the agency can look for the replacement.
Though a little expensive, agencies do tend to prove their worth in the long run as they take away a lot of your work like looking for freelancers, keeping track of their hours, providing updates, etc.
For example:– for a marketing campaign, the support also extends to evaluation, analysis and then tweak it to make it better. Also, agencies provide much more support than is possible for freelancers. You’ll be able to contact someone or the other at an agency , but if you’re not able to get through to the freelancer, you’re very much stuck where you are.
Disadvantages of the Freelance Projects
Freelance projects are more transactional in nature, they deliver on what they are asked and move on. While you may re-hire freelancers who have done well, the fact that freelancers work on multiple projects with different clients makes it difficult to establish long-term associations. Here a few other reasons why Freelance projects might not always be the right alternative.
Specialisation in selective fields means that for large-scale, complicated projects one freelancer might not be able to fulfill your requirements.
For e.g. , Someone specializing in graphic design, might not be able to build a website. So multiple freelancers might have to be brought on board, managing them can be a challenge. Freelancers prioritize their work as it suits them. Sometimes, you may want a crucial project to be delivered on a tight deadline, but they’d actually work on it with the same level of urgency is something, that you cannot know for sure.
Since freelancers work independently, there is no backup if they are not able to continue due to any personal or professional reasons. Looking for a replacement is difficult , and more often than not the work need to start from scratch. Although this is not very common, but when it happens, it sets back the project both in terms of cost and time.
Freelance projects are more transactional in nature, they deliver on what they are asked and move on. While you may re-hire freelancers who have done well, the fact that freelancers work on multiple projects with different clients makes it difficult to establish long-term associations. Here a few other reasons why Freelance projects might not always be the right alternative.
Specialisation in selective fields means that for large-scale, complicated projects one freelancer might not be able to fulfill your requirements. For e.g. , Someone specializing in graphic design, might not be able to build a website. So multiple freelancers might have to be brought on board, managing them can be a challenge.
Freelancers prioritize their work as it suits them. Sometimes, you may want a crucial project to be delivered on a tight deadline, but they’d actually work on it with the same level of urgency is something, that you cannot know for sure. Since freelancers work independently, there is no backup if they are not able to continue due to any personal or professional reasons. Looking for a replacement is difficult , and more often than not the work need to start from scratch. Although this is not very common, but when it happens, it sets back the project both in terms of cost and time.
Want to use inbound marketing to boost your startup’s marketing efforts?
Resources and Expertise Needed to Complete the Project
People:
Needless to say that without the right people no project is getting anywhere. Agencies make sure that they have the employees with right skill set available, whenever the requirement arises. This particular difference between freelancer and employee can make the entire difference in terms of the execution of your marketing program. Make sure to interact and get to know them, so that you know to approach any situations that may arise later.
Material Resources:
Even the best of people will be unable to justify their potential if the right tools aren’t available. A few examples of things generally considered essential
Software Licenses
Infrastructure-Eg. Good Internet Connection , PC’s with required specs, etc.
Equipments- like Cameras, Sound Systems, etc.
Of course, this might vary depending on the requirement of your marketing campaign, but make sure whoever you hire has access to what you need so that you don’t end up with sub-par work. Agencies usually have better resources at their disposal than Freelancers , given their scale.
Time & Money management:
All projects start off with a deadline and a budget, whether or not they remain unchanged throughout the duration of the project is a different matter. Therefore, managing time and money is a critical skill needed for completing any project. Be realistic while setting the budget and deadline, keep in mind what you want to accomplish and plan accordingly keep a little room for error. Delays and rising costs if unchecked can greatly reduce the utility of a project, so make sure that the people you work with do not take these things for granted. Here is a summary of pros & cons whether to go for an Agency or hire a Freelancer, to clear the entire confusion:
Agency
Pros
Cons
Professionalism
Expensive
Reliability to get the job done
Team dynamics
Suitable for the long run
Limited creative Liberties
Better support system
Broader availability of skill sets
Freelancer
Pros
Cons
Cost Effective
Can be Overburdened
Passionate about Quality Work
Availability can be an issue
More focussed in Chosen Field
Difficult to replace
Expertise limited to one or two fields
Limited scalability
Before you partner with an agency, it is important to know what you are stepping into. This checklist will help you evaluate the agency form every angle and give clarity in your marketing program path.
Conclusion
It really depends on the requirement, goals, scope, and the budget of your marketing campaign. Whether to select freelancer or agency for the task. Make sure to evaluate your marketing program in terms of the factors stated above. Which would help you decide if you need the services from an agency or a freelancer. And whether you need it on freelance vs. contract basis.
The fundamental distinction is between hiring an organization versus an individual. An agency provides a full team of specialists under one roof, while a freelancer offers deep expertise in a specific area, which directly impacts project management, cost, and the breadth of services you receive. Understanding this difference is crucial for aligning the right resource with your project's complexity and your team's capacity. For instance, agencies offer integrated solutions with built-in project management, whereas hiring freelancers requires you to manage coordination and integration yourself. This initial choice defines your level of hands-on involvement and shapes the entire execution of your marketing strategy. For a deeper look at how this plays out, the full article provides detailed scenarios.
The primary hidden cost of hiring multiple freelancers is the value of your own time spent on project management. While an agency's fee includes a project coordinator, with freelancers, you become the de facto manager responsible for sourcing talent, briefing each individual, aligning their timelines, and ensuring their work is cohesive. This management overhead can be substantial and divert your focus from other core business activities. For a complex project, this can lead to inefficiencies, communication gaps, and a final product that feels disjointed. Factoring in the cost of your internal time is essential for a true apples-to-apples comparison and for understanding the total investment required. Explore the full content to see how these costs accumulate.
An agency offers a turnkey, integrated solution for a website build, providing a coordinated team of designers, developers, and content writers who work in sync from the start. This model minimizes your management burden and ensures a unified outcome. Assembling a team of freelancers grants you more control over individual talent selection and can sometimes be more cost-effective upfront, but it places the full responsibility of project management, quality control, and integration squarely on your shoulders. The decision should hinge on two factors: your internal capacity for project management and your tolerance for risk. If you lack the time or expertise to coordinate multiple specialists, the cohesive, managed process of an agency is the superior choice for a complex undertaking. The complete article details further considerations for making this critical decision.
This example highlights the power of an agency's holistic execution model. Building a website requires the seamless integration of visual design, functional code, and compelling copy, which are distinct specializations. An agency provides a pre-vetted team where these experts collaborate under the guidance of a project manager, ensuring all components work together harmoniously. By contrast, if you hire individual freelancers, you must find each expert separately and then act as the bridge between them. The agency's value is in eliminating that coordination burden and the risk of a fragmented result, delivering a complete, professional solution without requiring you to be a project management expert. This core benefit is explored further in the complete analysis.
The 'superhuman freelancer' concept underscores a common strategic pitfall: expecting one person to master several distinct marketing disciplines. In practice, a business relying on a single freelancer for diverse tasks often receives average-quality work across the board rather than excellence in any one area. A great writer is rarely also an expert graphic designer or social media strategist. This can compromise the overall effectiveness of your campaign. For a multifaceted strategy, an agency's team of specialists ensures each component, from copy to visuals, is executed at a high level of proficiency, leading to a more polished and impactful result. Understanding this limitation is key to structuring your marketing efforts for success, a topic covered in greater detail within the article.
For a startup, making the right marketing hire requires a disciplined evaluation that looks beyond surface-level costs. Following a structured process ensures your decision aligns with both your budget and your strategic goals.
Define Project Scope: First, determine if you need a single, discrete task completed (e.g., logo design) or a complex, integrated campaign (e.g., a product launch).
Assess Internal Capacity: Honestly evaluate if your team has the time and expertise to manage vendors. If not, an agency's project manager provides significant value.
Calculate Total Cost of Ownership: Compare the freelancer's rate to the agency's proposal, but be sure to factor in the cost of your own management time if you hire freelancers.
Consider Long-Term Needs: Decide if this is a one-off project or the beginning of an ongoing marketing effort that might require broader support later.
This framework helps you make a strategic choice, not just a budgetary one. To see how these factors apply in different scenarios, review the full article.
The focus on core competencies elevates marketing from a simple task to a critical, specialized function that demands expert handling. This reframes the hiring decision as a strategic choice: are you outsourcing a task or a function? A freelancer is ideal for outsourcing specific, well-defined tasks, allowing your team to focus. An agency is better suited for outsourcing the entire marketing function, providing strategic oversight, planning, and execution. This implies a future where businesses will likely adopt a hybrid outsourcing model, using agencies for overarching strategy and complex campaigns while engaging freelancers for niche, specialized projects. Understanding this distinction is key to building a flexible and powerful marketing operation. The full article explores this strategic alignment in more detail.
The most frequent error is underestimating the project management burden required to make separate freelancers function as a cohesive team. Businesses often hire specialists for design, copy, and SEO, but fail to dedicate a resource to synchronize their efforts. To avoid this, you must adopt an agency mindset internally. This means you should:
Appoint a single internal point-of-contact who is fully responsible for the project's outcome.
Develop a detailed, shared project brief and timeline with clear dependencies for all parties.
Schedule regular, mandatory group check-ins to ensure constant alignment and resolve issues quickly.
This proactive management approach mitigates the risk of fragmented work and budget creep. To learn more about structuring these ad-hoc teams effectively, consider the models discussed in the full article.
The core difference lies in structural reliability and dedicated capacity for support. A marketing agency is an organization with a team, ensuring that someone is always available to assist you; if your main contact is busy, another team member can step in. Their business model is built on client retention and ongoing support. In contrast, a freelancer is an individual practitioner who often juggles multiple projects and clients. Their availability can be constrained, and securing their time for urgent or post-project tasks can be challenging. For businesses that require consistent access and dependable long-term support, an agency's organizational structure provides a more robust and reliable solution. The full article elaborates on how this impacts client relationships.
From a risk management standpoint, an agency's key advantage is its built-in redundancy and continuity. While a freelancer may be highly professional, you are still dependent on a single individual. For a high-stakes event like a product launch, any personal emergency, illness, or unexpected departure of that freelancer could jeopardize the entire timeline. An agency, however, functions as an organization. It has a team of professionals and established processes to ensure that work continues uninterrupted, even if one person is unavailable. This organizational safety net provides a level of risk mitigation that a sole practitioner cannot match, offering greater peace of mind for mission-critical projects. This element of professionalism and reliability is a central theme in the complete text.
The growing complexity of marketing directly favors the integrated agency model for high-stakes initiatives. Modern campaigns require a synchronized effort across data analytics, SEO, content creation, and paid media, a skill set that is virtually impossible to find in a single individual. As this strategic integration becomes the standard for achieving results, the value of an agency's cohesive team of specialists will rise significantly. While freelancers will remain the go-to for niche tasks, businesses will increasingly view agencies as essential partners for orchestrating complex, multi-channel campaigns that demand a unified vision and execution. To understand how to prepare your strategy for this shift, consider the insights in the full article.
The agency model is specifically designed to eliminate the bottleneck of individual availability. Instead of depending on one person's schedule, an agency provides a dedicated project coordinator or account manager to serve as your consistent point of contact (POC). This person's role is to be accessible, manage communication flow, and provide regular updates. Behind this POC is an entire team, ensuring that even if one specialist is occupied, your project progresses smoothly and your questions are always addressed promptly. This structure transforms a potential source of frustration into a streamlined, reliable, and professional communication channel. The operational benefits of this model are detailed further in the complete text.
Amol has helped catalyse business growth with his strategic & data-driven methodologies. With a decade of experience in the field of marketing, he has donned multiple hats, from channel optimization, data analytics and creative brand positioning to growth engineering and sales.
Growth Strategy and Planning
